Any
commentary done on the internet is likely to reference Google, being that Google
is possibly the most profitable, and influential website that has ever existed.
It is the ultimate switchboard, taking us anywhere online that our little heart’s
desire. As Cohen and Rosenzweig allude to, any new website builder must take
into account the effects of this popular search engine. In regards to their own
website, they have this to say: “Almost 60 percent of those who come to History
Matters arrive via a search engine, especially the currently dominant search
engine, Google, which gives us about three-fifths of that traffic. Thus you
need to understand how your site gets listed and ranked in Google.” (Pg. 148)
"Stoopid is as stoopid does" Forrest Gump |
But
for all of Google’s growing influence on our world an argument has emerged as
to whether or not this is making humans dumber. Google takes away the effort of
information gathering. We have outsourced our knowledge to Google. Google has
made us intellectually lazy. We don’t even need to know where we are going
anymore (in the real world) because Google Maps will get us to wherever we need
to go. These are arguments I’ve personally heard and understand to a certain
extent, but yet I can’t help but still view Google as a good thing.
The
sophistication of Google is astounding. As the authors point out, “Google found
a way to measure reputation on the web
through a recursive analysis of the interconnectedness of the medium itself.”
(Pg. 149) How is that possible? For a search-engine to be able to measure
something as amorphous as reputation, and effectively rearrange our search
results accordingly makes me feel not so much that Google is making me dumber,
but that Google is so much smarter than I am that it makes me feel dumb.
Sweet internet glasses Mr. President! |
Aside
from what Google initially set out to do as a search-engine, we might look
towards other business ventures they have made to determine if it’s making us
dumber. They have developed a self-driving car that we will see on the streets
soon enough. They have created new glasses that will bring the power of the internet
that one step closer to our brain. It’s probably only a matter of time before
they develop a chip to implant into our brains.
Google
is making the day-to-day tasks of our lives easier, which theoretically would
allow us time to pursue more,
whatever that might signify. Google is
changing the way humans operate in the world. As a company they appear as
concerned with inducing a paradigm shift as they are with making money. Personally,
I can’t help but appreciate their innovations.
I think that google has given us a plethura of,basically,useless knowledge. I can google just about anything,but who is to say if half of it is even kosher?
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand,google has given us the ability to filter through the bulky superfluities of,lets say,a certain book,in order to fish out exactly what information it is that we are looking for. But isnt it the journey and not the destination that is really important? I dont know,I just feel like with any internet-related aspect,it seems to be taking more and more from our nature as knowledge seeking creatures and is helping us look for that quick fix. Not that you dont bring some valid points to the discussion. I mean I cant really deny the sheer amount of easily navigable information readily available with google (just as long as one knows how to properly search).
Favorite quote: "For a search-engine to be able to measure something as amorphous as reputation, and effectively rearrange our search results accordingly makes me feel not so much that Google is making me dumber, but that Google is so much smarter than I am that it makes me feel dumb." I would have to agree with this, especially after reading about how they designed Google translate to literally learn from users how to translate better. Google is growing better all the time because of its users and its rather courageous approach to the web.
ReplyDeleteThis brings to mind Socrates' discourse on knowledge mentioned by Carr. He predicted that the devolopment of writing would be devastating to human wisdom because it would lead people to neglect to exercise their memories.
DeleteIt is really hard to discuss internet usage without talking about Google. After reading this week's readings, I tried to see how many times I used Google: 5 times in one browsing session. It's hard not to use, especially when there are so many websites out there. Its like a raft in a sea of websites :)
ReplyDelete